Your top 5 favorite Pink Floyd tracks!!!

[Rick and Roll]

There was no mention of the version of POTW by Jim that you stated. If that's the one, OK I can see it.

My post clearly states that I like the Gilmour Floyd songs much better than the Waters. Maybe it is you, Mr. Play, that needs to read more closely and talk less.

Animals IS my favorite Pink Floyd album! Did you notice Dogs and Pigs in my top 5? That's 2/3 of the CD!!!!!!!!

Wrong? All wrong? Isn't this just opinion?

Please don't take a quote out of context like that - you say I must be a pro-Waters yet I like Gilmour's compositions better? Whew!

Finally - if you are defending "Learning to Fly" as one of the greatest Floyd tunes, I am very disappointed.